POW Camp #1 - Page 9 |
|
XIII. Books & Videos/DVDsThere are over 100 books in print written by or about POWs -- there are probably hundreds more unpublished memoirs. I've made just a short list of some of the books I have; I wish I could read all the ones that are out there. Many of these books have descriptions at Amazon.com and some have reader reviews that are very useful. If you want to purchase some of the harder-to-find titles, a good site for used books is Bibliofind.com. Dr. Charles Roland has a very extensive bibliography in his book. Feel free to send webmaster Wes Injerd your recommendations. One of the largest collections of POW books and interviews has been assembled by Robert S. La Forte, professor emeritus of history at the University of North Texas, to which he donated his collection (article here). "I collect books regarding prisoners and captives of the Japanese in World War II. I have donated over 800 volumes to the University of North Texas Archives, which also holds approximately 200 interviews of POWs of Japan. The North Texas Library also has about 50 volumes which I did not duplicate with my holdings. All the books in my collection are in English and concern mainly Americans, Canadians, Australians, British, and New Zealanders. They also include a few Dutch and Asian captives." Of note are the many books written just after the end of WWII. A listing of the books can be found here: ROBERT S. LA FORTE COLLECTION AND U.N.T. ARCHIVAL HOLDINGS RELATED TO PRISONERS OF WAR OF JAPAN Also view this search at Amazon.com for all books relating to POWs (ranked by latest publication date). A broader search here at Google Books. See Recommended New Books for a list of additions with descriptions. POWs:Hidden Horrors: Japanese War Crimes in World War II, Yuki Tanaka, 1998 Prisoners of the Japanese in World War II, Van Waterford, 1994 This fact-filled reference book is a must for all students of POW history. It was compiled by one who knows what it was actually like to be a POW. The author (true name, Willem F. Wanrooy) was aboard the Junyo-maru when it was torpedoed on September 18, 1944. The ship was carrying 2,200 POWs of various nationalities as well as 4,320 Javanese conscript laborers -- a total of 6,520 souls! Only 880 survived, making it the worst maritime disaster in world history. Wanrooy was interned in POW camps for 3½ years. Prisoners of the Japanese: Pows of World War II in the Pacific, Gavan Daws, 1994 [A MUST-READ!!!] In the Words of Gavan Daws...
Unjust Enrichment, Linda Goetz Holmes, 2001 [Excellent!] "In these pages, American ex-POWs tell in their own words what it was like to be slaves for a Japanese corporation; to be used for medical experiments; to try and stay alive for weeks in the sealed hold of a Japanese merchant ship. Augmenting their words with secret Japanese orders, photos of POWs taken by Japanese companies and one brave prisoner, and her own research, the author pieces together how and why these things happened. It is a story being told fully for the first time. Unjust Enrichment makes powerful, authentic, and unforgettable reading. It also shows unmistakably why the companies of Japan owe thousands of American veterans compensation--and an apology." Long Night's Journey Into Day: Prisoners of War in Hong Kong and Japan, 1941-1945, Charles G. Roland, 2001 Another entry in the MUST-READ category for books relating to POWs, especially those men and women who served in the British Commonwealth, more particularly Canadian. Good coverage is given on seven POW camps in Japan: Osaka #2 (Narumi) and #3 (Oeyama), Niigata #5, Kawasaki (Yokohama) #3-D, Fukuoka #5 (Omine), Sendai #2 and Omori (Tokyo); also two Tokyo-area POW hospitals, Sagamihara and Shinagawa. The final two chapters are well worth the purchase of this book. The chapter Less Than Perfect Soldiers gives the reader much insight into understanding Japanese brutality. Sickness, starvation, brutality, and forced labour plagued the existence of tens of thousands of Allied POWs in World War II. More than a quarter of these POWs died in captivity Ghost Soldiers: The Forgotten Epic Story of World War II's Most Dramatic Mission, Hampton Sides, 2001 "Among the plenitude of wartime horrors, the Japanese treatment of POWs in World War II was among the most horrific, the Bataan Death March being one of the most notorious examples of the victors' brutality. By January 1945 a few hundred survivors were in a squalid work camp on Luzon, and Sides' book recounts a gung-ho military raid to rescue them--and to assuage American humiliation for their surrender in 1942. Sides opens with the proximate motivation for the mission: the Americans' fear that as they closed in on an increasingly beleaguered Japanese military, the Japanese would vengefully massacre their prisoners. Just such an atrocity had been perpetrated in December 1944 upon about 100 American POWs on Palawan. So as the Americans fanned out on Luzon, a unit of army rangers with Filipino support was sent ahead of the front line. Their plan, laid and led by Henry Mucci, worked perfectly, as does Sides' skillfully modulated narrative of the atmosphere, courageousness, and human cost of the operation." -- Gilbert Taylor, Booklist Death on the Hellships: Prisoners at Sea in the Pacific War, Gregory F. Michno, 2001 The Japanese treatment of prisoners of war in World War II has been written about before, but only with this chronicle will readers come to appreciate the true dimensions of the Allied POW experience at sea. It is a disturbing story that for many made the Bataan Death March pale by comparison. The survivors describe their ordeal in the Japanese hellships as the absolute worst experience of their captivity. Crammed by the thousands into the holds of ships and moved from island to island and put to work, they endured all the horrors of the prison camps magnified ten-fold. Belly of the Beast -- A POW's Inspiring True Story of Faith, Courage, and Survival Aboard the Infamous WWII Japanese Hell Ship Oryoku Maru, Judith L. Pearson On December 13, 1944, POW Estel Myers was herded aboard the Japanese prison ship Oryoku Maru with more than 1,600 other captives, almost 1,300 of them would be dead by journey's end ... Flyboys: A True Story of Courage, James Bradley, 2003 Flyboys is the true story of young American airmen who were shot down over Chichi Jima. Eight of these young men were captured by Japanese troops and taken prisoner. Another was rescued by an American submarine and went on to become president. The reality of what happened to the eight prisoners has remained a secret for almost 60 years. After the war, the American and Japanese governments conspired to cover up the shocking truth. Not even the families of the airmen were informed what had happened to their sons. It has remained a mystery--until now. Critics called James Bradley's last book "the best book on battle ever written." Flyboys is even better: more ambitious, more powerful, and more moving. On the island of Chichi Jima those young men would face the ultimate test. Their story -- a tale of courage and daring, of war and of death, of men and of hope -- will make you proud, and it will break your heart. My Hitch in Hell: The Bataan Death March, Lester I. Tenney, 1995 (Also in Japanese, Bataan: Toi Michinori no Saki ni, 2003) Rising from the Shadow of the Sun: A Story of Love, Survival and Joy by Ronny Herman de Jong, 2011 -- A historical account of 4 years in the life of women and children under Japanese oppression on the island of Java, based on the author's mother’s diary. Click here for the author’s website. My Time in Hell: Memoir of an American Soldier Imprisoned by the Japanese in World War II, Andrew D. Carson, 1997 Prisoner of Hope, Jesse Miller, 1989 Jesse Miller died on February 22, 2001. His wife, Nettie, recently sent me an article from The Denver Post about Jesse's life. It is another story about a hero, though Jesse probably would never have called himself that. Yet heroes are those who have qualities about them that others want to emulate -- like courage, the strength to go on, hope..... and forgiveness. Itchy Feet, Ted & Ardes Spaulding, 1999 In this down-home type book, Spaulding tells of growing up in North Dakota, joining the Coast Artillery and being transferred to a tank battalion which would later bring him to the Philippines. There he was captured while in Bataan and was on the Death March, and then later herded with some 1600 other POWs onto the hellship Oryoku-maru. He arrived at Fukuoka Camp #1 in January 1945. Read the excerpt below describing life at Fukuoka Camp #1.
Wake, War and Waiting.., Rodney Kephart, 1950 Read about Kephart's "Victory Flag" here. Captured on Wake Island on December 23, 1941, Kephart was shipped to mainland Japan to spend the remainder of the war in POW camps: Sasebo #18, Miyata #D12, Koyagi #2, and finally Orio #D9 (Mizumaki #6). While aboard a hospital ship, the U.S.S. Haven, anchored in Nagasaki Bay at the end of the war (see similar hospital ship), Kephart wrote home to his mother:I am almost at a loss as to what to do with myself after being cooped up so long... I am making every effort to bring myself back to the life that now presents itself before me. After the three years and nine months of slavery, torture and starvation, one is a little slow of thought and ignorant of the up-to-date things of life. I have found in the last 24 hours, from listening to the radio, many things mentioned that are absolutely foreign to me... It is such a relief to get away from the barbarous screaming of the Japs, the brutal treatment and the starvation and confinement. Then all of a sudden to be free, have plenty of food, good clothing, talk to civil people who talk and understand as yourself, and on top of all, be taken into this haven and treated like a royal guest. By the time I get home, I hope to have my head cleared and be ready to drop into life and make the most of my experience. Home by Christmas: Memoirs 1940 - 1948, Gerry Nolthenius, February 1998 (Limited copies available; read the excerpt below) - February 2002 photo of Gerry and his wife, Hennie - Sketch of Hakozaki camp showing where bomb hit that was intended for Najima Power Plant Any "book" has to have a title and this was a bit of a problem as "Memoirs" sounds a bit too expansive for a simple story. I remembered that during those years in captivity we were always rather optimistically talking about being "home for Christmas". In reality, it took me about eight years to get home for Christmas, but that is altogether another story.
Under the Samurai Sword, Clarence M. Graham, 1998 (Cal was shipped to Japan in July 1944 on the Canadian Inventor and was sent to Fukuoka Camp #17, Omuta. From there he saw the mushroom cloud on that fateful day in Nagasaki. See his article here, and also a CNN broadcast transcript (link outdated) on Larry King Live with Tom Brokaw.) This is a true narrative by Sargeant Graham, who tells of his amazing life of survival in the Pacific Theater during World War II. He starts with the peaceful life on a tripical island before the start of the war. He tells of battling the jungle conditions as well as the enemy during the battle of Bataan, then the battle of Corregidor and of being overwhelmed and captured by the enemy. He takes the reader through his three-and-one-half years in a prisoner of war camp under the inhumane treatment of the Japanese. Then the wonderful feeling of the return to freedom. It is a gripping true story of terrible atrocities told in a light and casual way. I Solemnly Swear, Robert Morris Brown, 1957 (Excerpt telling of his arrival in Fukuoka) I have in my possession an autographed first edition of the book "I Solemly Swear", written by my cousin, Sgt. Robert Morris Brown (1912 - 1998), in 1957. It is the true story of his experiences as a Japanese POW. Captured on Correigidor, he is a survivor of the Oryoku Maru. The book was not widely circulated at the time and is now almost impossible to find. He goes into great detail about both Japanese and American attrocities in the camps and on the prison ships, including black-marketeering, treason, vampirism, and cannibalism. Near the end of the book he talks about his experiences in Moji and Fukuoka. He tells the names and ultimate fate of many of the men who were with him, which may or may not be known. Before his death, I asked him if he belonged to any POW organizations, but he replied that he "was not a joiner." "Notify Alec Rattray...", Meg Parkes, 2002 A story of survival during WWII, "Notify Alec Rattray..." tells of two captivities - one, a young Scottish soldier held by the Japanese in Java and Japan, and the other his relatives back home in Britain. Father Found, Duane Heisinger, 2003 Baby of Bataan, Joseph Q. Johnson, 2004 The Fallen, Marc Landas, 2004 A Long March Home, Clarence K. Larson, 1998 An Angel on My Shoulder, Geoffrey Monument, 1996 Conduct Under Fire, John A. Glusman, 2005 Devil at My Heels: A Heroic Olympian's Astonishing Story of Survival As a Japanese Pow in World War II, Louis Zamperini, 2004 On May 27, 1943, Louis Zamperini's B-24 crashed into the Pacific Ocean. Louis and two other survivors found a raft amid the wreckage and waited for rescue. Instead, they drifted two thousand miles for forty-seven days. Their only food: two shark livers and three raw albatross. Their only fresh water: sporadic rainfall. Horyo: Memoirs of an American Pow, Richard M. Gordon, Benjamin S. Llamzon Knights of Bushido, Lord Russell, 1958 Frank Lovato's memoirs -- SURVIVOR: An American soldier's heartfelt story of intense fighting, surrender, and survival from Bataan to Nagasaki, Francisco L. Lovato, 2008 -- Here's what his son wrote me some time back: I am searching for an English language speaking person to discuss a segment of my father's book on his experiences as a prisoner of war in the POW camp Fukuoka Camp # 1. He was in the camp for about one year prior to the end of the war. He witnessed the sad fire bombing of Fukuoka and related how at the end of the war Fukuoka women and children came to the camp with chickens for eggs and began the process of peace. My father and his men gave the happy children chocolate candy bars and their mothers food that was dropped by parachute two weeks following the war. All of the stories are emotionally moving. I would love to communicate with anyone that also remembered those times. Photos of the site would also be greatly appreciated. Building for War - The Epic Saga of the Civilian Contractors and Marines of Wake Island in WWII by Bonita Gilbert (2012) - a thorough account dealing with the background of the civilian contractors on Wake Island. VIVISECTIONS:The Sea and Poison (Umi to Dokuyaku), Shusaku Endo (fiction) The Fallen: A True Story of American POWs and Japanese Wartime Atrocities, Marc Landas, 2004 When a rumor first crossed Special Agent Philip Cheles's desk in November 1945, there was no way to imagine the horror he would soon discover. Determined to uncover the truth behind an informant's report of a downed B-29 plane--and the assertion that one or more of the survivors had perished at the hands of local villagers--Cheles ultimately learned that nine soldiers had been captured and placed in the custody of the infamous Kempei Tai, the much-feared Japanese police. Further details surfaced about American POWs and their shocking fate. A benign investigation eventually exploded into the most sensational war crimes trial to come out of Japan. JAPANESE HISTORY:Japan's Imperial Conspiracy, David Bergamini, 1971 The Yamato Dynasty: The Secret History of Japan's Imperial Family, Sterling and Peggy Seagrave, 1999 Gold Warriors, Sterling and Peggy Seagrave, 2002 (Sequel to The Yamato Dynasty) "The Seagraves have uncovered one of the biggest secrets of the Twentieth Century." --- Iris Chang, author of The Rape of Nanking Magic: The Untold Story of U.S. Intelligence and the Evacuation of Japanese Residents from the West Coast during WW II, David D. Lowman, 2001 In late 1940 members of the U.S. Army Signal Intelligence Service broke Japan's highest level diplomatic code and then constructed a machine that was an analog of the one used by the Japanese. This allowed the U.S. to read Japan's diplomatic traffic from then until after the end of the war. Intelligence thus gained was cover named MAGIC because it seemed that only magicians could have produced it. BOOKS IN JAPANESE:
Disgrace: The Truth of the Kyushu University Vivisection
Incident (Omei:
"Kyudai Seitai Kaibo Jiken" no Shinso), Toshio
Tono, 1979, 1998,
Bungei Shunshu The True Story of the "Kyushu University Vivisection Case": An Empirical Record of the Last Witness (Shinso "Kyudai Seitai Kaibo Jiken"), 2019, Bungei Shunshu Vivisection: The Kyushu University Medical
Department
Incident (Seitai
Kaibo: Kyushu Daigaku Igakubu Jiken), Fuyuko
Kamisaka, 1982, Chuo
Koron-sha The Bell of Peace (Heiwa no Kane), Hiroshi Kudo, 1996 [About B-29 crash memorial in Takachiho] A Bridge Across the Pacific Ocean: Beyond the Tragedy of a POW Camp (Taiheiyo ni Kakeru Hashi: Horyo Shuyojo no Higeki wo Koete), Joetsu Japan-Australia Society, 1996 [Tokyo #4 Naoetsu] Preserving Peace: Beyond the Tragedy of Naoetsu POW Camp (Heiwa wo Mamoru: Naoetsu Horyo Shuyojo no Higeki wo Koete), Niigata Prefecture Board of Education, 1997 [Tokyo #4 Naoetsu] At a Mine in a Strange Land: A Record of Forced Labor at the Mitsui Yamano Coal Mine (Ikyo no Yama: Mitsui Yamano-ko Kyosei Rodo no Kiroku), Kaichosha, 2000 [Fukuoka #8 Inatsuki] VIDEOS/DVDs:Japanese War Crimes: Murder Under the Sun, Lou Reda Productions (A & E Entertainment, 2000) [Soon to be in Japanese!] History Undercover: The Bataan Death March, A & E Home Video, 2000 Sleep My Sons: The Story of the Arisan Maru, Shawnee Brittan Productions for Westar Entertainment, 1997 Wake Island (1942), Universal Studios, 2001 Three Came Home (1950), Gotham Distribution, 2002 Paradise Road, 20th Century Fox, 1997 ("Set in World War II Singapore, European women imprisoned by the Japanese seek solace from the horror of their imprisonment by forming a vocal orchestra.") Song of Survival, Janson Associates, 1985 -- The documentary version of Paradise Road. They survived three-and-a-half years in a Japanese prison camp in Sumatra during World War II. But these courageous women had something special going for them: the great music of Beethoven, Schubert and Chopin. Having no instruments but the human voice, they recreated from memory the complex symphonic music they had loved. Even as disease and malnutrition thinned their ranks, these Australian, Dutch and British women - missionaries, teachers, nuns, wives and children - used their unique choir to sustain a spirit that refused to accept defeat. Here is their remarkable story, told by the survivors themselves, aided by rare archival footage To End All Wars, 2001, Argyll Film Partners Changi, 2002, Australian Broadcasting Corporation Prisoners of the Sun, 2004, Uav Corporation (original Australian movie, Blood Oath, 1990) Brian A. Williams (writer / producer of Blood Oath) was kind enough to share with us the following: Bataan Rescue, Paramount Home Video, 2005 (PBS page American Experience: Bataan Rescue) The Great Raid, Miramax, 2005
XIV. POW IssuesA. Lawsuits (LAWSUIT PAGE)Lester Tenney (see the chapter on the Death March from his book) is the first American ex-POW to bring a lawsuit against a Japanese company asking for compensation for forced labor during his captivity in Japan. He visited us in December 1999 and we went down to where the largest POW camp in Kyushu once stood -- Omuta Camp #17. He often comes to Japan to give lectures. Following are some letters and articles telling about his lawsuit and visit to Omuta. Also included is his speech to the U.S. Senate and letter to former President Clinton. Tenney's Letter to Center for Internee Rights magazineAugust 18th, 1999 Upon advice of my council, I have been unable to tell you until now about my legal confrontations with the Japanese Company Mitsui, regarding my forced labor, personal damages and the need for an apology. As you may recall, Mitsui is the corporation that owned the coalmines in Japan where I was forced to work under inhumane conditions during my years as a POW. At 8:30 a.m. on August 11th, 1999, my Attorneys filed a Lawsuit on my behalf in the Superior Court of Los Angeles County, California. One of the reasons we decided to take this Action was Senate Bill 1245, which eliminated the Statue of Limitations for those cases involved with slave labor. This California Legislation was signed into Law by the Governor of California on July 27th, 1999. A very important, but perhaps overlooked provision of the new Law is that it allows not only survivors of Japanese POW camps to bring an action, but also specifically allows heirs of survivors to bring actions. The Law Firm representing me is Herman, Middleton, Casey and Kitchens, a national Law Firm that has a large number of outstanding trial lawyers in a number of states. The members of this firm have successfully sued many national and multinational corporations, including the tobacco industry, the asbestos industry and Exxon in the Oil Spill Litigation. As you know, a lot of the corporations that used POW labor in Japan include some of the largest companies in the world today, such as Mitsui, Yodogawa Steel Corporation and others. It is clear that the requirement, both monetary and research expertise, needed to successfully sustain lawsuits of this nature requires a firm with substantial resources at their disposal, and I have such a law-firm. I realize the impact this Bill and my Lawsuit means to other POW or their heirs and because of that I hereby give you permission to share this information with members of CFIR, so that they may benefit from these events. With best personal regards, I remain (signed) Les Tenney Newspaper article re lawsuit (Aug. 13, 1999)U.S. ex-POW sues Mitsui for forced labor Visit to Omuta
NishiNihon Shinbun (West Japan Newspaper)December 9, 1999 Lester & Betty Tenney at news conference in Omuta DECEMBER 8 -- 58 YEARS FROM THE START OF THE WAR FORMER AMERICAN POW VISITS OMUTA "MITSUI'S RESPONSIBILITY HAS NOT DISAPPEARED" Former college professor from the U.S., Lester Tenney (79), on the 8th, after 54 years, visited Omuta City's old Mitsui Miike Mine site where he worked in forced labor during WWII. At a press conference which was held afterwards at Omuta City Hall, Tenney made his appeal: "Mitsui profited from the forced labor, and for its own honor it must apologize." Tenney told how he became a POW as a soldier in the Philippines and then was forced to work in the mine from September 1943 until the end of the war. "We had to dig tunnels using dynamite, very dangerous work. We were made to work 12 hours a day. I started out weighing 85Kg, but when I was set free I was only 40Kg," said Tenney, looking back on the harsh labors in the coal mine. In July of this year, a new law was enacted by the State of California lengthening the statute of limitations for seeking war reparations by those forced to work during WWII. Tenney in August filed a lawsuit with the California Court asking for compensation from the Mitsui Mining Company. In regards to his lawsuit Tenney remarked, "Even though
the
Mitsui Miike
mine has closed down, Mitsui's responsibility for the inhumane use of
POWs
for forced labor has not disappeared."
|
U.S. House paves
way
for POW lawsuits WASHINGTON (Kyodo) -- The U.S. House of Representatives has passed by an overwhelming majority a budget provision barring the administration from blocking former U.S. prisoners of war from filing slave-labor compensation lawsuits against Japanese companies. The provision, which cleared the lower chamber Wednesday by a 395 to 33 vote, bars the State and Justice departments from using government money to oppose slave-labor lawsuits on grounds that the United States has given up compensation claims against Japan under the San Francisco peace treaty. The Senate has yet to act on the measure, which was sponsored by in the House of Representatives by Congressman Dana Rohrabacher, D-Calif. The U.S. State Department has submitted briefs to U.S. courts in support of the Japanese government's rejection of lawsuits on the grounds that the 1951 San Francisco treaty had settled all wartime claims. According to historians, about 50,000 U.S. servicemen were taken prisoner by the Japanese during World War II. About half were sent to Japan, where many were forced to perform hard labor, mainly in steel mills and mines. |
About the San Franciso Peace Treaty of 1951 and its relevance to compensation claims:
The claim that Japan settled the issue of war
reparations when she signed the San Francisco Peace Treaty (hereinafter
"SFPT") is entirely groundless. In point of actual fact, the SFPT does
not settle ANY claims for reparations between Japan and the other
signatories but merely provides the machinery under which such claims
could be settled at some unspecified future time. "It is recognized,"
states the treaty, "that Japan SHOULD pay reparations to the Allied
Powers for the damage and suffering it caused during the war.
Nevertheless it is also recognized that the resources of Japan are not
PRESENTLY sufficient, if it is to maintain a viable economy, to make
complete reparation for all such damage and suffering and at the same
time meet its other obligations," (emphasis added). Furthermore, the
treaty specifies that the bilateral negotiation that Japan would
henceforth enter into with the aggrieved nations in question would be
for "the damage done," the question of punitive fines or apologies is
never addressed.
Second, contrary to what some have claimed, neither South Korea nor the People's Republic of China were signatories to this treaty. This is a simple indisputable historical fact. It is not subject to interpretation of any sort. At the time the treaty was signed, the PRC, along with the Soviet Union and India, explicitly refused to recognize it. They viewed it for what it was, an instrument of US imperialism and a legal codification of Japan's status as a military vassal. That this was the case can hardly be disputed as the US championship of the treaty was contingent on Japan accepting the bilateral security treaty with the US that has been the cornerstone of US Far East policy ever since. Third, the treaty addresses only legal obligations between nation states. It does not touch on moral obligation, which is most often the issue being discussed when Asian nations and their peoples protest the policies of the Japanese government and its ministers, and it does not touch on compensation to individuals. Though all of these facts are certainly significant, perhaps the most relevant part of the treaty with regard to the recent controversies over Japan's attitude toward its past is that by signing it, Japan specifically accepted the judgment of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East in a legally binding document. Arguably, Japan rendered the entire treaty null and void when, after the occupation ended, it commuted all of the sentences of the class A war criminals convicted by that tribunal still serving time. Furthermore, it does so again every time the Japanese Prime Minister officially worships at Yasukuni Shrine as Prime Minister Nakasone did in 1985, and Prime Minister Koizumi has promised to do this year. When the prime minister worships in an official capacity, the Japanese government gives official sanction to the effective rejection Yasukuni made of the findings of the tribunal when its priests chose to enshrine the seven class A war criminals sentenced to death by that tribunal, as fallen martyrs and war dead. -- From the discussion board at Japan Today |
THE QUAN
|
December 24, 2001 article from People magazine on Lester and Betty Tenney: "Lester Tenney's 60-year War"
Lawsuit updates continued on LAWSUIT UPDATE PAGE.
Fukuoka Camp #6, also known as Orio Camp, was located in Mizumaki, northeast of Fukuoka City. Since most of the POWs were Dutch, a group of ex-POWs from the Netherlands set up this gravesite memorial several years ago. You can read about Dolf Winkler and his desire to establish this memorial site, and the tireless efforts of Hiroshi Kurokawa in making Winkler's dream become a reality. This is truly a story of how wounds can be healed. The town of Mizumaki has a page on the Memorial Cross on its website as well. This article I found interesting, with large portrait of Winkler (Traces of war: Dutch and Indonesian survivors).
[Dutch] Foreign Minister and other officials visited Kyushu area to offer a prayer before the cross "When turning our eyes on the dark aspect of bilateral ties between Japan and the Netherlands, we see how much pain the war brought to both countries. The names are engraved in our memories of the war." The above was a portion of a speech delivered by Dutch Foreign Minister Van Aartsen on April 21 at Mizumaki Town in Fukuoka Prefecture in a heavy rain. In front of the Cross Tower on which names of 869 ex-Dutch POWs who died in Japan during WWI were engraved, there assembled the Foreign Minister and 120 Dutch Navy servicemen. They were visiting Japan to attend the commemorative event marking the 400th anniversary of Japan-Netherlands relations and placed a wreath of flowers on the Cross Tower. Among the ex-POWs was Dolf Winkler (83). He was held as a POW by the Imperial Japanese Army that occupied Indonesia and brought to a coal mine at Mizumaki Town in 1944. After the war, he went back to the Netherlands and later became manager of a designing firm. When he became 50 or so, he began suffering from nightmares, always shouting, "Help me!" His doctor told him, "You are still bearing the burden of the war within you." In order to overcome the terrible memories, he made up his mind to dare to re-visit Japan. In 1985, he visited the site of the coal mine where he had lost many fellow internees. There, he found a cross still standing in the graveyard although half-buried in the earth. The cross was presumably hurriedly put up as a grave marker by the mining firm after burying the dead POWs. The mining firm did so because it feared it might be pursued for its war responsibility. But the graveyard was left to run wild. Winkler, in cooperation with local historical writer Eidai Hayashi (66) and others who guided him to there, appealed to the town government to preserve the cross well. Later, getting assistance from a civic group at Mizumaki Town, he came to visit Japan almost every year to offer a wreath on the cross together with ex-POWs and ex-detainees. Since 1967, the Japanese Government, as part of its "project to bridge between Japan and the Netherlands," has invited Dutch persons who attend the wreath-offering ceremony there. "If those suffering the wounds from the war visit Japan, they can realize the Japanese they will see with their own eyes now are different from those in they remember from the time they were tortured by the Japanese. This is the way I became released from the 40 years of suffering." From: DAILY SUMMARY OF JAPANESE PRESS Monday, May 15, 2000 AMERICAN EMBASSY, TOKYO POLITICAL SECTION OFFICE OF TRANSLATION SERVICES |
A monument memorializing prisoners of war is at Soto Dam in Yunoki near Sasebo, set up in April 1956 by the city. The POWs were from Fukuoka Camp #18, located about a quarter mile above the dam construction site. In the mere 6 months this camp was in operation, some 65 POWs lost their lives during the construction of the dam. Read these excerpts from the affidavits of those who were there.
Photo of monument, Junshokusha no hi, "Monument to those who died in the line of duty" Photo of name plaque listing the 14 Japanese and 31 Americans who lost their lives Photo of top of dam . See Camp Profile PDF file (in Japanese only, listed as fk18_soutou_j.pdf in URL) for maps of this site. UPDATE: A new plaque was installed on May 30, 2010, which reflects an accurate list of the men who perished at this camp. See THE SOTO DAM MEMORIAL for more information and photos.
B-29 Crash Site: Erected on May 5, 1977, this cenotaph commemorates the 11 airmen aboard the B-29 as well as the Japanese pilot whose plane hit the B-29. See here for more about this monument and the airmen's fate. A memorial service is held each year at the monument on May 5.
B-29 Crash Site: At 9:10am on May 7, 1945, a B-29, the "Empire Express," went down on Mt. Hachimen in Sanko-mura, Oita-ken, after colliding with a Japanese twin-engine fighter. It had just finished "bombs away" over the target, Usa Airfield, when the fighter clipped the B-29's left wing. There were only three survivors: T/Sgt. Edgar L. McElfresh, Sgt. Ralph S. Romines, and Sgt. Otto W. Baumgarten, all from the 483rd Bomber Squadron, 505th Bomber Group, 20th Air Force Command. The "Empire Express" was the only aircraft lost out of eleven assigned to bomb Usa. Sgt. Tsutomu Murata, the 27-year-old pilot of the fighter plane, did not survive.
The three airmen were brought to the Fukuoka Detention Camp at Western Army HQ, and a little over a month later were taken out to meet their tragic and horrible deaths. That graphic story can be found here. See also Michael Berg's research on the Empire Express and executions. For a list of the airmen, see this Japanese webpage.
A peace monument was set up at the foot of Mt. Hachimen initially by the landowner, Masayoshi Kusunoki, in the early 50's as a memorial to both the Americans and the young Japanese pilot who died in the area. A larger monument (Japanese webpage here) was completed in 1970 by a group of Japanese along with some U.S. officers from Itazuke Air Base (see also this PDF, mostly in Japanese). Yearly memorial services are held at this site on May 3rd and include representatives from all over Japan, including Iwakuni Marine Corps Air Station, making this site the most prominent in all of Kyushu. In the words of one visitor: "I've been to the Washington D.C. monuments to the various wars, Arlington National Cemetery, and the Nagasaki and Hiroshima Atomic Bomb memorials and peace parks. None of them compare to the monument on Hachimen Mountain. It is unique because it was built and maintained as a monument to U.S. soldiers on the Japanese homeland."
Each stone
imbedded on
the face of this monument
represents a life expended in search for peace.
May this monument stand as a constant reminder of the futility of
war.
--Inscription on the Sanko Peace Park memorial monument--
B-29 Crash Site: The B-29 that crashed here on August 30, 1945, was enroute to Miyata POW Camp #12. It was on its final mission, loaded with relief supplies that were to be air-dropped over the newly-liberated, and very undernourished, POWs. Unfortunately, the supplies never reached their intended destination, for the plane went down due to poor visibility and crashed into the side of Mt. Sobo, killing all 12 crew members. (For detailed information and photos of target camp sites, see the 20th Air Force Report on POW Supply Missions to China, Korea, Formosa, Manchuria and the Japanese Home Islands. See also Relief of Prisoners of War and Internees.)
Some 900 POW supply flights were run right after the end of WWII, and most had to fly at dangerously low altitudes over mountainous terrain, often with limited visibility. A total of 8 aircraft and 77 airmen were lost.
Villagers nearby hurried up the mountainside in search of survivors. They only found their bodies amidst the charred remains of the aircraft and its contents scattered everywhere -- clothing, medical supplies, combs and toothbrushes, fruit juice, cocoa.
Through the efforts of many local Japanese, the "Prayer for Peace" Monument was erected on August 26, 1995, as a memorial to those who died. Each year around the 26th of August a memorial service is held at this site in Sanshudai. See this website for photos of the memorial stone and plaque showing the names of the airmen who died.
Hiroshi Kudo has written an excellent book (in Japanese with some English) dealing with some of the aspects of this fatal flight as well as a young Japanese fighter pilot whose plane also crashed in the Takachiho area only a few weeks earlier. This 222-page book, The Bell of Peace, is available from Mr. Shunsuke Ogata at The Takachiho Community Center, 1515 Mitai, Takachiho, Miyazaki 882-1101. The cost is ¥1500. You can read a translation of an article he wrote on how he discovered this crash site, as well as an assortment of other information on this flight (including a list of the airmen) and the monument on that same webpage.
B-29 Crash Site: This B-29 crashed on April 29, 1945, during a bombing mission over Miyakonojo Airfield in Kagoshima-ken. All crewmen aboard died in the crash; only 9 bodies were recovered and buried. See list of airmen here.
Outside of Kyushu, another important site is the Naoetsu Peace Memorial Park in Niigata in central Japan, built on the former site of the Naoetsu POW Camp #4B. Most of the POWs there were Australians. A book about the site and events leading up to its construction are recorded in A Bridge Across the Pacific Ocean. An excellent 80-page work for use in elementary and junior high schools was produced by the Niigata Prefectural Board of Education in 1997 and titled, Preserving Peace: Beyond the Tragedy of Naoetsu POW Camp (Heiwa wo Mamoru: Naoetsu Horyo Shuyojo no Higeki wo Koete). Additional website here.
Located east of Hiroshima where mostly British POWs were interned at Hiroshima POW Camp #4B. For an explanation of this site, see the Peace & Friendship Monument and Wall Plaque. Also visit their website. Read about an American flag made by POWs at this camp. Another American flag story here (PDF file).
9. Emukae Memorial, Fukuoka Camp #24
This camp just north of Nagasaki was "home" to over 200 British and Australian POWs. See special page on Neil MacPherson and Owen Heron visit to Emukae and dedication ceremony for this memorial. See Camp Profile PDF file for more information (Japanese only).
10. Nagasaki Memorial for Alien War Victims: Fukuoka Camp #14
For British, American, Australian, Dutch, Indonesian and other Allied POWs who were at Fukuoka Camp #14 -- some 300 were exposed to the A-bomb with between 50 and 60 dying. See Camp Profile PDF file for more information (Japanese only). (Click on images for enlarged view. Images courtesy of Taeko Sasamoto.)
There were some 3,600 crewmen who went down in their B-29's over Japan
during
World War II. Of those who parachuted out and survived, at least 150
were
killed where they landed by local townspeople. Over 40 others soon died
due
to injuries. In Osaka, out of 53 airmen taken, 8 died of their wounds,
6
were given poison-laced coffee, and the rest were shot and then buried.
In
Kobe, 43 airmen were either shot or beheaded. In northern Japan, 47
were
executed. In Kyushu, 43 airmen were either shot, beheaded or dissected
alive.
Out of the 530 airmen who became POWs, less than 50%
came back
to the
U.S. alive.
Former Camp Commandant Shirabe:
Merry Christmas, Mr. Shirabe by Asami Nagai The Daily Yomiuri July 29, 2000 FUKUOKA -- On Oct. 31, 1998, N.G.J.W. Van Marle, a former Dutch prisoner of war during World War II, was finally reunited with Masaji Shirabe. The two men, bath wrinkled and. gray-haired now, had not seen each other for 55 years, not since the days Van Marle was a POW in Shirabe's labor camp near Nagasaki. As commandant, Shirabe, now 85, was known for his humanitarian treatment of internees in his charge. "It's been a long time and I don't recall much," he said. "My motto as a camp commandant was to treat internees as equal people with rights and dignity that should be respected. That's all." Shirabe was a would-be priest-turned-soldier who had studied theology at Doshisha University in Kyoto. On Oct. 22, 1942, he met about 1,200 Dutch, British and American POWs arriving at Nagasaki Port to transfer them to his camp on a nearby island, where they were to labor in the dockyards. As commandant; he allowed the prisoners a self-governing system under 27 officers, made possible through the preservation of the Allied troops' own military hierarchies. A Dutch officer who had long worked at a Kobe trading company acted as interpreter, liaising between the POWs and their Japanese overseers. Shirabe declared one day a week a holiday. As a devout Baptist, he permitted internees to celebrate Christmas, and even went so far as to invite a priest from a local church into the camp. In the climate of wartime Japan, it was perhaps inevitable that his way of treating POWs was criticized as "too lenient," Shirabe said, adding that on one occasion he even took them out of the camp to attend Mass at a Nagasaki cathedral. "I never saw them as enemies," he recalled. "Rather, Japanese soldiers gave me the biggest headache, because some of them stole internees' personal belongings." The organizers of an exhibition on the Japanese occupation of Indonesia, slated to open in Japan Aug. 1, decided to use Shirabe's story as one of the personal histories on display. "He decided for himself how to act in wartime. I think it is an important message that people have to make their own decisions in such circumstances," said Erik Somers, exhibition director of the Netherlands Institute for War Documentation and curator of "Dutch, Japanese, Indonesians -The Japanese Occupation of Indonesia Remembered." Just before Shirabe was transferred to another camp in early 1943, he asked one internee to sketch all 27 officers' portraits, and requested each officer to add his signature. This memento, which the former commandant has treasured ever since, was of great help when Von Marle visited him two years ago. "He looked just like his portrait on this piece of paper. Seeing this, I soon remembered him," Shirabe said with a chuckle. The artwork and a photo showing the reunion of the two former enemies -with Van Marle pointing at his own portrait -will be on show at the exhibition. "With them, we wanted to suggest that there is a possibility that enemies can live together during a war," Somers said. Shirabe surely proved this point. A black-and-white photo taken on Dec. 25, 1943 at a camp in Yamaguchi Prefecture shows him smiling shyly while POWs raise a toast, surrounded by Christmas decorations. After the war, Shirabe became a priest and moved to Okinawa Prefecture, where he and his family remained for 35 years. These days, they tour nursing homes and kindergartens around the nation, using puppets to dramatize Christian teachings. "In the years following the war, we often wondered what those internees were doing when they returned home," said Shirabe's wife of 60 years. |
Article on lawsuit to obtain war-time files:
War-files law aims to get answers, compensation: Suit filed against Japanese companies may expose secrets, difficult memories By Michael Doyle Bee Washington Bureau (Published Feb. 25, 2001) WASHINGTON -- Sixty years ago, Tracy resident Melvin Routt fell into the hands of the Japanese Imperial Army. What happened next, as a prisoner of war and slave laborer on Japan's home islands, is indelibly etched in Routt's memory. But the broader historical memory of what happened to other American, Chinese and Korean prisoners remains in some cases locked away in secret archives. Now, a newly enacted law could help pry open the World War II files. "They kept records on everything that happened pretty much, you know," said Routt, 79. "There certainly should be information in (the files) that can prove our point." Routt's specific point is, in part, a legal one. He and other former prisoners of war are suing Japanese companies, in hopes of gaining financial compensation for their treatment. The yellowing war files now maintained by the CIA and other secrecy-minded agencies could establish links between the prisoners' treatment, Japanese government policy and Japanese corporations. "I'm sure there are records," said 79-year-old Fresno resident Harry Dunlavy, a retired Marine sergeant major who spent three winters at a Japanese POW camp in Manchuria, "but I suppose they would have to be in Japan." Dunlavy, like Routt, is part of the lawsuit against Japanese companies. He was forced to work at a tool-and-die company. In the first Manchurian winter, nearly one-third of the men Dunlavy arrived with died. So far, he said, "the damn Defense Department has just sat on" the ex-POWs' courthouse efforts. But the new law, modified from legislation first introduced by Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., is meant to serve more than the discovery needs of veteran plaintiffs. More broadly, proponents believe, it will help keep history honest. "Without historical accuracy, you're never going to get justice," said Ivy Lee, a Sacramento resident and retired sociology professor. "Justice could be in the legal sense, but it could also mean that Japan does not go around whitewashing history." Now president of the Global Alliance for Preserving the History of World War II in Asia, Lee was among the grass-roots lobbyists pushing for the archives-opening law. A native of Macau, Lee is particularly keen on uncovering what the Japanese Imperial Army did in China starting in 1931. "That was way before what we usually think of as the start of World War II," noted Lee, who formerly taught at California State University, Sacramento. Prompted by Lee, Routt and affiliated groups, Feinstein initially authored legislation setting up a special task force to examine Japanese Imperial Army records going back to the 1931 Japanese military incursion into Manchuria. Congress previously had established the Nazi War Criminal Records Interagency Working Group, which recently declassified more than 2.5 million pages of World War II records. Eventually, as part of a fiscal 2001 intelligence authorization bill, Congress approved a modified form of Feinstein's effort. It adds to the roster of the Nazi war criminal records group a specialist on Asia, and it extends the task force's life by another year. It's not all sunshine, though; shadows can remain. The law establishing the original Nazi records group explicitly exempted the task force from a part of the 1947 National Security Act, which gives U.S. intelligence agencies tremendous leeway in withholding information. But that exemption disappeared by the time lawmakers finished their latest work. This could return to already-skittish agencies more power in denying access to the Japanese files, though lawmakers say they still intend openness to remain the watchword. The task force has not yet named its Pacific war specialist. It has, though, added a historical adviser, Linda Goetz Holmes, author of books including "Unjust Enrichment" about American POWs in Asia. "There are still probably a significant number of records that have not yet been declassified," said Holmes, who added that she hopes the uncovered files might help identify "people who are war criminals and where are they now." No one knows exactly how many relevant files exist in U.S. custody. Steven Garfinkel, director of the federal Information Security Oversight Office and chairman of the Nazi War Criminals Interagency Working Group, said the task force probably will "end up surveying millions of pages." The amount eventually released will certainly be less than that uncovered by the group's Nazi war criminal records focus, though still meaningful for individual veterans. "Anybody in the Army would be interested in finding out what happened," said Modesto resident Eugene Brush, who was interned by the Japanese as a civilian. "They should all be interested in it." Now 82, the former Pan American Airways mechanic was imprisoned for three years after being captured in the Philippines. He worked as a cook in the Santo Tomas camp for "enemy aliens," and though he harbors no love for his former captors, he said "there weren't any atrocities unless you went over the wall." He feels no burning need to peruse the files that may be uncovered on the Santo Tomas camp. Japan, so far, has kept closed many of its World War II records. The United States returned to Japan in the 1950s the files that had been scooped up by U.S. forces at the end of the war. American officials only copied about 5 percent of the records before returning them in February 1958. "I understand you have to have secrets, but these things occurred 60 years ago," said Sheldon Harris, an emeritus history professor at California State University, Northridge, and author of "Factories of Death: Japanese Biological Warfare 1932-1945 and the American Cover-Up." Slave labor like the kind Routt endured will be one compelling focus of the augmented task force. Another will be the Japanese Imperial Army's experiments in biological and chemical warfare, some details of which have been surfacing in recent years. In 1945, Routt watched and felt and smelled from across the bay while the city of Nagasaki was consumed in an ungodly mushroom cloud. Some time after the atomic bomb dropped, and Japan had surrendered, Routt returned to his home country and a lifetime of bad memories that some might prefer to keep locked away. "This," Lee said of the archives-opening legislation, "will bring to light all of the secrets." |
POW Plight Allied WWII prisoners of Japanese still suffer By Milton Combs Tokyo Weekender May 26, 2000 During World War II the Japanese held more than 140,000 Allied troops as prisoners of war. Many of these Allied prisoners became forced slave laborers for Japanese companies, working long hours under dangerous and extreme conditions. For these ex-POWs there has been little support from their governments in winning compensation for their suffering. Because of years of neglect, ex-POWs are now seeking compensation—still without support fom their governments. In March of this year, an article in the Washington Post reported that last September 500 survivors of the infamous 1942 Bataan Death March suffered by American and Filipino prisoners of war filed a joint suit against five Japanese companies for slave labor. The article added that on Pearl Harbor Day, Dec. 7, 1999, the flamboyant New York attorney Edward D. Fagan, (known for his $5.2 billion settlement with German companies that cooperated with the Nazis and a $1.25 billion settlement with Swiss banks for hiding the assets of Holocaust victims) filed a class action lawsuit against Japanese industrial giants Mitsui, Mitsubishi Corp. and Nippn Steel Corp. On Feb. 16, 2000, The Daily Yomiuri reported that many of Australia's 3,000 surviving prisoners of war will join a class action lawsuit against Japanese mining, construction and manufacturing companies, and banks that profited from slave labor during the construction of the infamous Burma Railway during World War II. Companies targeted by this action include Mitsubishi Corp., Kawasaki Heavy Industries Ltd., Nippon Steel Corp., Showa Denko K.K. and Mitsui & Co. With Germany's recent payment of compensation to victims, the focus is now on Japan. But what were the actual working and living conditions of POWs of the Japanese during World War II and do they warrant reparation? Father Hildebrand Yaiser, a Benedictine monk who spent more than 50 years in Japan, was asked by the Swiss Ambassador early in 1942 to be his representative for war prisoners and internees in Japan. Although there were a large number of camps, he was allowed to visit only a few, being told by the Japanese military that they had no obligation to show him any, and that he was being shown certain camps as a favor. Let's hope the camps Father Hildebrand Yaiser visited were not selected because of their superior conditions. In his autobiography, he wrote about what he saw: "At Yokohama, the poor soldiers had to sleep on wooden planks covered with straw. The room was completely dark. All windows had been nailed shut with boards, and the men especially complained about the darkness. They were emaciated, dirty and neglected." He also writes of speaking to a British brigadier, commander at another camp: "He told me his men were dying en masse, like flies. The imprisoned military doctor was about ready to beg me on his knees to bring him some medicine." Working and living conditions are also presented in reports dated July 31,1946, titled "Prisoner of war camps in Japan and Japanese-controlled areas as taken from reports of interned American prisoners," compiled by the American Prisoner of War Information Bureau. In these reports the internees tell the horrors of their experience. A report from Fukuoka POW camp No. 11 describes the danger of the coal mines, work that many prisoners were forced to do: "Cave-ins were common and deaths were caused by these sloppages. The prisoners were constantly aware of this danger, and their nervous anxiety was a greater menace to their health than the actual work, according to the camp surgeon." A report from Hakodate branch camp #2 at Utashinia on Hokkaido states: "This project was digging coal in an old mine which had about 'worn out." No attempt was made to replace rotting mine props or overhead beams and, while no reports are made of fatal accidents, many of the prisoners were badly hurt by falling rocks and cave-ins." Prisoners were forced to work even when sick. A report concerning a camp at Tsuruga gives evidence: "Prisoners pronounced to be too sick to work by the prisoner camp surgeon were beaten because they could not stand up to the work program." Brutality also existed in the camps. "Two guards—indicated only by nicknames as 'Gorilla" and 'Blackjack," along with the medical assistant—were extremely cruel in their beatings of the prisoners, and, in most cases, the prisoners themselves did not know the reasons. The beatings of the prisoners, frequently into insensibility, were administered for the slightest cause, generally unknown to the offender, and were so cruel and damaging as to require hospitalization." This testimony comes from Fukuoka Camp No. 10 at Futase on Kyushu. Malnutrition was the cause of many deaths of POWs. From Fukuoka camp No. 17, the report states that although the men were forced to work long and laborious hours in coal mines and zinc smelters, the American camp doctor stated that the "food ration was insufficient to support life for a bed-ridden patient. All of the prisoners were skeletons having lost in weight an average of around 60 pounds per man." Medical care was often denied to prisoners. At Fukuoka Camp No. 1, medical officer Hata was described as incompetent, inconsiderate and brutal. Here are the words of one prisoner: "I would like to emphasize strongly that the Japanese doctors in this camp are not worthy of any consideration whatsoever, that they were very neglectful in their duties and at times refused to supply medicine to the American officers who were dying of pneumonia and whose lives could have been otherwise saved." At this camp, under the command of Commandant Yuichi Sakamoto, and with 1st Lt. Medical Officer Hata, 193 American prisoners were interned from Jan. 30 to Apr. 25, 1945. In this three-month period, 53 men (28% of those interned) died. In these reports prepared by the War Information Bureau, it should be noted that in some camps the prisoners were treated in a fairly considerate and humane manner. Sadly, these are the exceptions. For the vast majority of POW camps, the reports are painfully all too similar. Beatings, along with lack of sleep, inadequate food and medical care resulted in the deaths of large nmber of prisoners. Over all, the death rates of POWs under Japanese control were atrociously high. Gavan Daws, in his book Prisoners of the Japanese ,details the disturbingly high death rates of prisoners held by the Japanese. The American death rate was 34 percent, the Australian death rate 33 percent and the British 32 percent. In comparison, American POWs of the Germans had a death rate of 4 percent. Sadly, the suffering did not end with the finish of the war. Many POWs suffered from post-traumatic shock syndrome, a condition not recognized as a medical problem until after the Vietnam War. Gavan Daws writes in Prisoners of the Japanese: "In the first ten years after the war, while most of them (POW survivors) were still young, only moving out of their late 20s into their 30s, their death rate was higher by far than that of civilians of their age, and considerably higher than that for war veterans who had not been prisoners. By age 40, proportionally far more of them were dead." Justice? Have allied POWs of the Japanese been fairly compensated for the suffering they endured while working for Japanese companies as forced laborers? Were the families of those who did not survive captivity fairly compensated? According to the Japanese companies and the Japanese, American and British governments—and still supported by the Clinton and Blair administrations—the answer is "Yes." Their position is that all reparation claims against Japan were waived under the San Francisco Treaty negotiated between Japan and 48 nations and signed in San Francisco on Sept. 8, 1951. Lawyers for the POWs, meanwhile, argue the treaty only covered state-to-state claims and does not affect claims by individuals against Japanese corporations. A closer look at The San Francisco Treaty shows that there are no direct references to individual reparations. Article 14 of the peace treaty indicates that the focus was on areas occupied by the Japanese, not on the Allied troops sent in to clean things up: "Japan will promptly enter into negotiations with Allied Powers so desiring, whose present territories were occupied by Japanese forces and damaged by Japan." Why was the issue of compensation to Allied POWs overlooked in the San Francisco Treaty? A look at what was happening in the world at that time may give indications. By the autumn of 1948 it was clear the Communists were winning in China. There was a growing division between the forces of free enterprise led by the United States and the forces of Communism lead by the Soviet Union. Japan, because of her once-considerable industrial power, was viewed as an important factor in this worldwide contest. On June 25, 1950, the Communist regime of North Korea invaded South Korea. The United States became heavily involved militarily in the Korean War and would need military bases in Japan to support the war just across the waters. The geo-politics of the cold war had become a factor in peace negotiations between Japan and the U. S. It is no accident that on the same day as the signing of the peace treaty, a bilateral security pact between the America and Japan was signed. Although Article 6 of the peace treaty states, "All Occupation forces of the Allied Powers shall be withdrawn from Japan as soon as possible after the coming into force of the present Treaty, and in any case not later than 90 days thereafter," the security pact provided for the continuation of American bases and forces in Japan. To make the bilateral security treaty negotiations go smoothly in order to guarantee American bases in Japan, it is possible that the potentially embarrassing and unwelcome issues of crimes against humanity were ignored. The suffering experienced in the camps is made more acute by what many ex-POWs and civilian internees of the Japanese feel has been neglect—and even abandonment by their own governments—in seeking justice and compensation. Their numbers dwindling with each passing season, they have taken matters into their own hands. For those still alive, Germany's recent settlement and the recruiting of attorney Edward D. Fagan to their cause, ex-POWs of the Japanese have renewed hope that justice, to some degree, will finally be achieved for them, and for those still remembered. |
Amazing Story of Rodney Kephart and the Victory Flag at Camp #6 -- Similar stories of other flags made and flown at POW camps at liberation:
Two days after the British discovered us, the first B-29s came over, and the sky seemed filled with parachutes, some red, some white, and some blue. Some of the larger loads were carried in two 55-gallon drums welded end to end and the remainder in single drums. Occasionally a chute would not open, and the load would plummet to the earth like a bullet and explode with a frightening force on impact. On one occasion, there were three or four Japanese civilians sitting a round a small table having tea and hoping to gather up some food left on the ground. A chute carrying gallon containers of canned peaches came plummeting to earth and landed squarely in their midst. They never knew what hit them: killed by canned peaches.With these multicolored parachutes, men of the three nations represented in that camp began making handmade flags of their respective countries. They were crude, but to us they were beautiful. On September 2, 1945, we hoisted them from poles set in the ground on the beach as we sang our respective national anthems. Four hours later, the surrender documents were signed aboard the U.S. battleship _Missouri_ in Tokyo Bay. (The U.S. flag we made in camp is on display at the Pioneer Village Museum in Minden, Nebraska, Capt. Thompson's home state.) -- From "We Were Next To Nothing" by Carl S. Nordin (1997), POW at Yokkaichi Camp #5
See also Some men will never forget 'Bataan' --
While in prison camp Omtevedt, along with other prisoners, made an American flag from red, white and blue parachutes used by American planes to drop food supplies. [PHOTO OF FLAG]It was 11 a.m. Aug 18 when the Japanese lowered their colors and the makeshift American flag was raised. It went up before any American forces reached Japanese soil and was the first to fly over Japan at the end of the hostilities.
It was raised daily until Sept. 13, 1945, when the prisoners marched to freedom. Omtvedt carried the flag at the head of the column.
Omtvedt kept the flag and later presented it to the U.S. Government. It was placed in the Pentagon and is now in the museum at F. Lee, Va.
Another story of a US flag made by POWs (PDF file)
Article by Hiroshi Kudo on B-29 crash in Takachiho:
Excerpt from Northern Miyazaki's Nature Preservation Association Journal, "Tsuchibinoki," No. 2. THE WAR IS OVER ("Sobosanchu B-29 Tsuiraku Hiwa") By Hiroshi Kudo President of Northern Miyazaki's Nature Preservation Association A mountain becomes a stage for various dramas. Since ancient times many of these dramas which have influenced both animals and human beings have become more elaborate with time. Generally, there are various cases in which a mountain becomes a stage for a tragic comedy. Once the drama ends, the mountain, the stage, recovers to a state of calmness, not unlike how it was in ancient times, untouched and towering high above. This effect from long ago has linked ties between people and mountains, and it is a fundamental occurrence which has become well respected. Because these dramas take place deep within the forest, there are many cases in which a single character stars, loses his life, and the facts about him become lost for future generations. I will explain one such case. It involves twelve young officers, whose spirits sleep on a mountain in a foreign land. I pray their spirits rest in peace. On August 30, 1945, only a couple weeks after the war had ended, a B-29 plane named "The Flying Fort" (Fuselage No. 44-61554) headed to Kikuchi City, Kumamoto Prefecture. It flew across the mountain ridge between Mt. Katamuki and Mt. Sobo, past the Bungo Channel. It was flying at an altitude of 1600 meters through dense fog just before a heavy rain fall. According the Miyazaki Region Weather Observatory, at 10 a.m. weather conditions recorded by the Mitai Observatory Office (located in present-day Takachiho) were as follows: Temperature: 24.2°C Wind Direction: -- Wind Speed: 0 Degree of Cloudiness: 10 Signs of Rain Existing Humidity: 99% Rain Fall: 5.5mm It is certain that the B-29 was traveling under these conditions of extremely poor visibility due to rainfall. From November 1, 1944, nine and one-half months before the end of the war, 17,500 planes dropped 160,000 tons of bombs on major cities all around the country, scorching and altering the land. These planes were also of the B-29 type. On August 6, 1945, in the middle of the night the bomb-loaded B-29 "Enola Gay", commanded by Captain Paul Tibetts, Commander No. 509 of the U.S. Army-Air Force Squad No. 20, left Tinian Airfield. On the same day at 8:30 and 17 seconds, this B-29 released its bomb, instantly reducing Hiroshima to ruins. On August 9, the B-29 "Bockscar" piloted by Lieutenant Sweeney also left from the Tinian base. At 10:58 it dropped a bomb on Nagasaki. Because of the dropping of these two "new-type" bombs on what was supposed to be "indestructible divine land," Japan agreed to an unconditional surrender. Thus, the war came to an end. With the feeling of finally being able to return to their hometowns, Chief Pilot Henry Baker and eleven other crewmembers attempted to fly just over the mountain ridge extending from Kyushu's Mt. Sobo to Mt. Katamuki. All were experienced in flying bomber aircraft over long distances. All fought in the war, risking their lives for their country. However, even these soldiers of the victorious country were probably in slight disbelief that they had survived the war. They were positioned according to their seating arrangements on board their plane weighing a total of 46 tons with a width of 43 meters and length of 43 meters. They sat unaware of the tragedy about to occur only seconds after entering the dense fog mixed with light rain. Some of these men were possibly lighting a cigarette; again, some may have been gazing at a picture of their loved ones whom they thought they would be able to see soon. Not having to worry anymore about the attacks by persistent small Japanese Army fighter planes or about flak from anti-aircraft guns, they were quietly performing their last duty, flying through the skies of Kyushu. Their plane attempted to fly over an area about as high as the mountain ridge connecting Mt. Sobo (1757m) and Mt. Katamuki (1603m), near the peak of Mt. Shoji. Right at that moment, a dreadful disaster occurred. A section of the plane made contact with the top of the ridge, instantly causing the plane to crash and be engulfed in flames. Not even the slightest chance of escape was possible. As the vast sky seemed to turn into a ball of fire, Pilot Jack L. Riggs of the U.S. Army-Air Force plane gave out a sorrowful cry. His plane crashed on the northwestern slope of Mt. Oyaji (1644m) causing a blast of destruction, mowing down trees of enormous magnitude existing in the virgin forests. The quiet, thick forests of beech, white oak and "Himeshara," over which a thick fog lay mixed with light rain, became the stage where this terrible tragedy took place. The twelve young men on board were in miserable condition after being thrown out of the plane, which scattered. The scene of this sorrowful accident was a picture that could only have been of hell. When I heard about this crash, this news was not quite as old as it is now. Two years ago one day in October, I was hiking as usual within the areas of Mt. Sobo and Mt. Katamuki to continue my research on the habitation of Japanese bears. After I set up a tent in Shikimibaru, my two colleagues and I hiked slowly toward Mt. Shoji from Mt. Oyaji. This hike took approximately 30 minutes. At the beginning of the hike there was large downward incline leading to the center of a saddle located between the two mountains. At the lowest point of the saddle I looked down at my feet to discover a shiny metal object protruding from the ground. With much effort I was finally able to unearth it entirely. It was made of stainless steel, decorated elaborately with engraved numbers and about fifteen alphabet letters, and fastened securely by rivets. This object looked much like a part belonging to an airplane. I thought to myself, "But why did it fall from the sky? And why it is here?" As I walked while holding the object in my hands, I thought about this odd find for a long period of time. I hiked to Bear Monument located on Mt. Shoji and placed the object next to the monument. When I was a child, I had heard from my father that an American transport plane flew very low in the skies just above my hometown, Mitai District, Takachiho Town, Nishiusuki County, Miyazaki Prefecture. It flew toward Mt. Furusobo (1633m) and Mt. Hontani (1642m), flying across the ridge formed by the two mountains. The plane crashed after coming in contact with trees in present-day Obira Pass, a part of the prefectural highway running through the Takachiho-Ogata area. The site of the accident, however, was geographically different. I thought that this plane accident must have been, therefore, a separate occurrence. One day in the winter of the same year, after passing the hillsides of Mt. Furusobo and Mt. Shoji, on the Toroku Forest Road which passes through the Obira Pass, I met up with an acquaintance who was a boar hunter. I asked this local man about the plane accident that occurred within the vicinity. Quicker than I expected, I learned about the facts of the accident. It seems on a rainy day not long after the end of the war near Mt. Oyaji, there had been an American military plane which crashed killing about ten people. He remembered that there were a number of people who went out to collect the relief supplies, making their way through the bamboo grass at the crash site. They picked up and brought back pipes made from unknown metals, bullets, helmets of the deceased, etc. Talking with the man I was finally able to confirm that there was in fact a "plane crash." However, it was not known clearly when it happened, what type of plane had crashed, what had happened before the crash, and who was on board. The feeling of not knowing the concrete details of the crash created a strong urge within me to conduct some research. What was known was that this accident occurred during a time of great confusion right after the War. Moreover, this was a time when, just a short time before, Japanese people thought England and the U.S.A. were enemy nations. Exactly how much research could be done regarding the accident concerned me. While engaged in my research, many things were discovered about the crash by pure coincidence. The first discovery occurred at a second-hand bookstore in Nobeoka. Without any real objective in mind, I came across a book which contained a summary about the accident. This summary gave me giving me more information about the accident. When I opened the book to the article on the B-29 crash, I would never have guessed that such information would be obtained in this way. The book dealt mainly with the history of the hardships endured by farmers reclaiming their land after the war. It was written by Mr. "K," who was a member of the village at the foot of Mt. Sobo. Reading this information left a great impact on my life. I will always remember it. I would like to insert the following condensed version of the summary: ------------ One rainy day, just after the war had ended, an American Army Air Force B-29 plane crashed near Mt. Shoji with a loud boom. We pushed our way through the land and searched the mountains to find the relief supplies. In a time of much need of these supplies, we wanted the goods for ourselves to use. We found the crash site, glanced at the ten or so blue-eyed dead American soldiers pitilessly, and picked up the canned goods as well as other usable goods and brought them home. Some days passed when a jeep from the occupational army came to our village. Coming in actual contact with these Americans and watching them pick up every single article to take back to their home country, I became ashamed of myself, and still am, for thinking such wicked thoughts. ------------ After reading the article, I was finally able to obtain the whole story behind the accident, which I first learned about only after finding that single stainless-steel object. Coincidences seem to run in groups. A few months later, I went to Kumamoto Prefecture on a business trip. The taxi driver seemed to speak in my native dialect so I conversed with him to make certain this was true. My intuition was correct. I discovered that his hometown was the village at the foot of Mt. Sobo. The conversation extended to my asking about Mr. "K" and the story about the B-29 crash. It turned out that this driver was actually Mr. "K's" younger brother! He said that at the time of the crash Mr. "K" hurried to the crash site. He explained further that most of the debris had been piled in the area, now known as the front of the Gokasho Bus Station, and transferred to somewhere in Kagoshima. Upon hearing his story I immediately visited the crash site to reconfirm these facts. Since the Third Annual Nature Observation Trip was expected to take place in May 1990 in the Mt. Oyaji-Mt. Shoji region, it was decided that members of the observation group, Mr. Katakabe, Mr. Matsuda and I, would simultaneously take part in the trip as well as make preliminary inspections of the crash site. I surveyed the position of the metal fragment I found two years ago and designated this area as the "main" area. The distance between the ridge and this area was barely 60 to 70 meters long. I was hiking down in the direction of Mt. Kuro, when a strange sight suddenly came to my attention. In the vicinity of the destruction, covering a large area, trees were not permitted to age any further after the crash occurred. In other words, not a single tree over 45 years old presently exists in this area -- in the awesome debris, not one tree had survived. In addition, all together ten objects were found -- bulletproof walls made of asbestos, rubber hoses, objects made of duralumin (an alloy of aluminum) destroyed by the enormous impact, electrical system cords, and objects similar to superchargers with exhaust valves. The cogwheels connected to the supercharger that were made of a considerably hard alloy were completely altered. It appeared to have been rotating at a fairly high speed just before the crash occurred. After placing all of the accumulated objects together in one place, the three of us thought quietly about the American soldiers and offered silent prayers. I was reminded by this event that I was born in a generation completely ignorant of what war is really like. Hiking through the mountains, I thought about the men, whose souls lie here within these mountains in my hometown, and how they did not know a single person here. Right then it became clear to me that someone had to assume the responsibility of passing on these facts to future generations. It was a strong feeling that dwelled in my heart. To start, I gathered all of the facts concerning the accident and determined to contact the Authorities on American Affairs in order to somehow record these facts for posterity. As it was obvious that I lacked the ability to write a letter in English, I asked Mr. Atsushi Tomokane of Hinokage town whether or not he would help me to contact the authorities. He had lived in the U.S. for a long period of time and had himself been in the military. He readily accepted my request and promptly telephoned a worker at Yokota Military Base in Tokyo. He also wrote two letters to the Air Force Historical Research Center in Alabama to inquire about the crash. He informed the Center of the contents of the research including the August 21, 1945 date and all of the information we collected. Soon after we received a reply from one of the archivists, James H. Kitchens. The letter stated that the Center could not confirm any of the facts concerning the accident and requested that we reconfirm the date of the accident as well as any other pertinent information. After conducting a series of interviews, the date of the accident was again determined to be August 21. It was possible that the date was inaccurate, but we thought some type of information similar to our own could be obtained from the Center. We realized that our data was not as precise as it should have been and were partly prepared to give up hope. It was then that we received another letter from Mr. Kitchens. It was a genuine coincidence that the date Mr. Tomokane received the letter was August 30. We were finally able to confirm the fact that the B-29 crashed in the Sobo mountain range exactly 45 years ago on this date. Apparently Mr. Kitchens had contacted another post to confirm the information. According to the files on August 30, 1945, the B-29 (Fuselage No. 44-61554), piloted by 1st Lt. Jack L. Riggs of the 45th Bomb Squadron, 40th Bomb Group, crashed instantly killing all twelve crew members on board. A written report containing thirty pages of detailed reasons for the crash accompanied the letter from Mr. Kitchens. Although the introductory passage only briefly described the accident, the rest of the report included detailed information such as results of the soldiers' autopsies and the remarkable method used to identify the bodies as well as ages of the soldiers. Also included were the names and ages of the witnesses and other people connected with the research work. According to the report, the bodies were wrapped and buried. Six crosses were placed in the ground to serve as temporary burial ground markers for the twelve men. On the 27th and 28th of August the following year, people from the American Military Division in Fukuoka City visited the crash site to confirm and remove the bodies. They gently turned up the soil and reconfirmed the bodies' existence. The deceased men's personal belongings included a picture of a woman with black hair, a Ronson lighter, a graduation ring, a card for good fortune, etc. After a year of examining each person's identification tag, personal belongings, hair color and other useful sources, all bodies were positively identified. While reading the report, I thought about how the American officers quickly but carefully dug up the shallow graves, thinking to return the remains of their peers to their homeland as soon as possible. Words cannot express the emotions I felt as I thought about what had taken place. Although it is unknown as to what happened after this event, it is certain that all twelve crew members, always together in any military activity, now rest peacefully at Arlington Cemetery. As I felt a deep sense of regret for my lack of study in English, I sat at my desk alone, holding a dictionary in one hand, and attempted to translate the rest of the written report. I followed each and every word and phrase of the poorly photocopied sheets. Unexpectedly, images more vivid than from reading any Japanese material welled up in my mind while translating the written report into Japanese. The thought of young soldiers from a foreign country losing their lives on a mountain in my home country moved me deeply. The scene which became the stage for this tragedy is even at present surrounded by thick forest. The forest colors express the change from season to season as though nothing has happened to disturb its cycle. People who know about these American soldiers are few. A memorial monument does not exist and not a flower from any of the four seasons has been offered to the deceased soldiers. Through the cycle of seasons, flowers have naturally covered the area where the spirits of the deceased soldiers rest, and little birds' warble to comfort these men's souls. At the end of the report, an account of the twelve crew members' names, ranks, and I.D. numbers were given as follows: Name, Rank, I.D. Number 1. Riggs, Jack L., 1st Lt., 0-750848 2. Cornwell, John G., 2nd Lt., 0-778342 3. Williamson, George H., 1st Lt., O-865008 4. Eiken, Alfred F., 1st Lt., 0-685455 5. Baker, Henry B., Cpt., 0-375237 6. Frees, Henry N., S. Sgt., 16079237 7. Dangerfield, John David, Cpl., 39913681 8. Groner, Solomon H., S. Sgt., 32818450 9. Gustaverson, Walter R. S., Sgt., 13129760 10. Miller, Bob L., Cpl., 39931488 11. Hodges, John W., Jr., Sgt., 33645761 12. Henninger, Norman E., Sgt., 15323591 (Note: Most men at the time were about 20 years old. It was determined from his body that Sgt. Hodges was under 2O years old.) Postscript: On August 30, 1945, at 2:05 p.m., a B-29 (Fuselage No. 44-61554) carrying twelve crew members crashed on Mt. Oyaji located in the Sobo Mountain Range. Six hours later, a silver C-54 airplane flying from the east showed itself in the skies above Atsugi Air Field. It was General MacArthur's personal plane the "Bataan." Wearing a khaki-colored uniform, smoking a corn-cob pipe and wearing black glasses, General MacArthur stepped out of his plane and said, "It was a long ride from Melbourne to Tokyo. It was an extremely long flight with many difficulties, but it looks like it's all over." THE WAR IS OVER! A new era for Japan had just begun. In reality, the lives of many people were sacrificed, leaving their loved ones behind. For the benefit of future generations, I promptly printed everything that had happened within the past two years. I believed that this task would be difficult for a poor man living in the mountains like me. I had only learned about a segment of the war by chance. Nevertheless, I committed myself to this purpose. This essay is the product of my commitment. It is a long essay for what was supposed to be a small bulletin notice, but it was intended to introduce this tragic accident. In my next essay I would like to write out the entire contents of the 30-page written report. During my research on the B-29 crash, it was found also that a small one-passenger Japanese fighter plane crashed at the foot of Mt. Sobo in the same year on July 27. It was learned that in another incident, an American military transport plane crashed after hitting the Ohira Mountain Pass, killing four of its crew members. On these above mentioned accident sites, I would like to somehow have memorial monuments built so that they will be remembered by future generations. On May 12, 1958, a crash occurred in the vicinity of Mochida Valley of the Okue Mountain Range. This disastrous accident, which killed four of the crew members, involved a Yamato Airline Beaver plane. A memorial monument has been built in memory of those who died and many people are aware of this accident. Although research on the B-29 Crash has not been completed, I would like to express my gratitude for the invaluable assistance given by Mr. Atsushi Tomokane of Hinakage, Mr. Keiji Anzai of Kawachi, as well as other members of the research project. When plans for building the Memorial Monument dedicated to the twelve men are finalized, I would again like to ask the members of the research project for their assistance. Resource Materials: "Daichi No Tsume Suru Omoi," Daisan Bumeisha "Tokyo wo Bangeki Seyo," Sanshodo Sensho "B-29," Sankei Shinbun Shuppankyoku "Nihon Senryo," Sankei Shinbun Shuppankyoku "Omei -- 'Kyudai Seitai Kaibo Jiken' No Shinso," Bunsho Bunko |
The POWs of the "Doolittle Raiders" with Testimony by DeShazer
Medical Officer Hewlett's article on Omuta Camp #17, Nightmare Revisited:
DAI JU NANA BUNSHO [CAMP #17] NIGHTMARE REVISITED by THOMAS H. HEWLETT, M.D., F.A.C.S., COL. U.S. ARMY RETIRED Dec. 1978 We were expended as F.D.R. predicted and thus became guests of the Emperor. As such we departed Manila on 24 July 1943 in the hold of Mate Mate Maru, 500 adjudged fit for heavy manual labor by Japanese doctors. Our cruise ship had a 155-mm cannon lashed to the bow with heavy rope, this represented our anti-aircraft fire protection in case our cruise was interrupted by American air attack. Two doctors and a medical warrant officer were assigned to keep the detail in good health. En route Manila to Japan our ship stopped at Santa Cruz and took on Manganese ore, July 31st found us enjoying the beauties of Taipeh Harbor in Formosa. Jerry Okonski, one of the group, became very ill during the Formosa visit. The gracious Formosan and Japanese guards could not see fit to move him ashore for the necessary emergency surgery, so utilizing a hatch cover table and dental novocain in the spine, removal of a ruptured appendix was carried out in bright sun light. About 7 days later Jerry Okonski was able to walk off the ship carrying his own possessions. However, the government would not compensate him for loss of the appendix. We finally arrived in the Port of Moji 9 Aug. 1943, and after a brief delay termed a "Quarantine," we traveled by train to Omuta where the civilian population stoned us in welcome as the first contingent of prisoners of war to enter Camp 17, Fukuoka Military District. Contrary to a recent publication our trip was a safe one, we lost no men and thus buried no one at sea. As POW's we worked in the mine and foundry..... I have chosen to review with you factual material from a medical report on Camp 17 which was compiled by the Medical Staff: Capts. Ian Duncan & Richard Parker, Australian Army, Lts. Harold Proff and Theodore Bronk, U.S. Army, and Lt. Gerit Bras, Royal Dutch Army. It is ironic that this report was accepted into the Australian Army Museum for its historical value. Our meager records including the death list were not acceptable to a U.S. Courts Martial since they were not typewritten. I was young and inexperienced with the system in those years so at this late date I apologize for not keeping a typewriter with me. The medical report was completed Aug. 25, 1945 while the medical staff was still together in a complete state of recall to review the period, utilizing our private records as concerned each nationality group..... As the camp increased in population, doctors who joined us were assigned to work in their field of interest. We were young and not fully trained. As an example, Dr Bras, interested in laboratory work, arrived in camp with a crude microscope constructed of bamboo tubing and field glass lens. Thus we gained an additional capability in diagnosis and it became possible to cross match blood. Medical supplies for the camp was a joint responsibility shared equally by the Mitsui Corporation and the Army. Eventually hospital space increased from a combined dispensary and ward building to one adequately large clinic building and 6 ward buildings: 1 isolation ward of 9 beds, 3 medical wards of 30 beds each, 2 surgical wards, 1 of 30 beds, 1 of 58 beds, to a total of 187 beds or mats. Thru the humaneness of Baron Mitsui, a 1919 Dartmouth graduate, we did have bed space for the sick and wounded. Those of us who remained at Camp 17 following the exodus of the guard detail in Aug. 1945, set out to scavenge the city of Omuta. Early in the exploration we found several warehouses packed with Red Cross food and medical supplies. The dates of receipt and storage indicated that these items had reached Japan prior to Aug. 1943. Thus while we suffered from lack of food, essential medicines, surgical supplies, and x-ray equipment, these items, gifts of the American people, were hoarded in warehouses during our two years in Japan. The reason we were denied these essentials remains a top secret of the Imperial Japanese Army..... Deficiency diseases were a continuing medical problem and despite repeated pleas to the Japanese command we were never able to obtain any dietary improvement. The Allied Medical officers considered the basic problem to be total dietary deficiency while the Japanese considered it as beriberi, the so-called classic patterns of Vitamin B deficiency. The first case of deficiency edema (swelling) that appeared in the camp in Dec. 1944, this patient literally wasted away. Within 10 days after the polished rice was introduced into camp, edema was noted in increasing number of prisoners, as polished rice eliminated our only source of Vitamin B and reduced the major nutrients..... GASTRO-INTESTINAL DISEASES: There was a consistently high disability rate from diarrhea. To clarify one point, amebic dysentery was never a problem in Camp 17, only 7 cases were diagnosed by microscoptic exam and 3 of these were under treatment in Aug. 1945. Medically we used 4 classifications for gastro-intestinal diseases: 1) FOOD DIARRHEA (HIROHITO'S CURSE): On at least 3 occasions 75% of the prisoners were struck by an epidemic, in the fall of 1943 following questionable fish soup thru the mess hall, whale blubber, or the rare issue of clams always produced such a temporary epidemic, usually these outbursts tended to recede in 48-72 hours. These patients always demonstrated undigested food in the stool. Purgation and total abstention from food were effective in handling such epidemics. 2) ACUTE ENTERITIS (BENJO BOOGIE): These patients gave a history of 3-4 days of diarrhea, with as many as 15 stools per day. They did not respond to an aniline purgative available in small amounts from the Japanese Army. Bed rest was our only successful mode of treatment. 3) ACUTE COLITIS: This condition was undoubtedly bacillary dysentery, it was prevalent during the summers of 1944 and 1945, at which time 30 hospital beds were constantly utilized for its treatment, during both periods Japanese denied the existence of the disease outside camp bounds. Yet prisoners employed in the mine reported Japanese miners suffering with it. One Japanese civilian employed in Camp 17 died of the disease in the early summer of 1945. Sanitary public health measures within the camp were instituted, but no public health measures were taken in the Japanese guard housing area and none in the surrounding civilian areas. 4) CHRONIC INTEROCOLITIS: Required long hospitalization and bed rest and a strict diet of lugao with warm tea enemas. This could be a terminal disease in severe malnutrition cases. RESPIRATORY DISEASES: PNEUMONIA: Our most dreaded killer, pneumonia continuously maintained the highest mortality rate of any of the infectious diseases. In the winter of 1943-44, among the men of the first detail, the morbidity rate was 8%. The same group, during their second winter in Japan, showed a morbidity rate of 3%. Both the Australian and Dutch details who arrived in camp for the second winter showed the higher morbidity and mortality rates. It should be noted that the second Australian detail which arrived Jan. 1945, showed the highest morbidity and mortality of any group in this camp. They arrived from the tropics during the wintertime. In considering the pneumonia in this camp, one cannot ignore certain living conditions which contributed to the development of this disease: 1) Starvation diet. 2) Continuous exposure to extremes of temperatures 32 -105 in the mine; some men worked in water. 3) Persistent upper respiratory irritations in all miners as a result of the irritating gases encountered. 4) Lack of adequate heating facilities within the camp. Diagnosis of pneumonia depended upon the physical findings. The lower lobes were the most constantly involved. Total pneumonias for the period reached 250 cases and were classified as follows: 1) Broncho-pneumonia-------20% 2) Lobar-pneumonia-------80%..... Due to the limited supply of drugs available, treatment was not instituted in any patient until positive consolidation could be demonstrated. X-ray was never available. Total deaths from pneumonia were 48, of these, 10 were in a state of extreme emaciation when they contracted this disease. The highest incidence of the disease occurred during the winter of 1944 and spring of 1945. During these periods 50 to 60 were in the hospital. In March of 1945, there were 14 deaths from pneumonia. This was the highest total for any month. The average period of hospitalization was 20 days, followed by 30 days of convalescence in quarters. TUBERCULOSIS: Most Americans with even minimal tuberculosis died early in Philippine Island prisons. Pulmonary tuberculosis first appeared in the first detail of this camp in March 1944, after 7 months of mine work. It was impossible for this prisoner to have had contact within the camp bounds with a case of active tuberculosis. One of the Japanese overmen assigned to his group apparently was troubled with a chronic productive cough. This overman stated that he was troubled with consumption. This case was diagnosed by stethoscope and later confirmed by x-ray. There have been in the camp a total of 11 proven cases and 4 suspects. Of the 11 cases, 8 were from the American group and 3 of the 8 lived in the same room during the first winter in Japan. Treatment of these patients was limited to hospital bed rest. Six of the 11 proven cases died prior to Aug. 23, 1945. FUKUOKA FEVER: Dengue-type fevers are endemic in all Far Eastern countries. Navy personnel will remember Cauite Fever of the Philippines. For want of a better name a local endemic fever encountered in this camp was termed "Fukuoka Fever". Very little satisfaction was ever obtained from the Japanese concerning this condition although the disease ranged from 60% to 70% of the entire camp. It may be described as an atypical aching, profound malaise, loss of appetite, and profound weakness. There is no rash and the length of the disease varied from 6 to 15 days. The prevalence of the disease coincided with the mosquito season. The temperature showed a tendency to run high the first 2 to 3 days of the illness returning to a low level for a period of 5 days, to rise again for 2 to 3 days prior to cessation. The severity of the symptoms varied with the temperature, the response to salicylates and codine was only fair. The disease conferred no immunity and 1 recurrence was likely during the season. It was impossible to keep these patients from duty status except when temperature was demonstrable. Subjective symptoms had to be ignored. This condition was developing a high morbidity rate during August 1945. MALARIA (BLACK WATER FEVER): Of the population in this camp, 88% had suffered from malaria in the tropics. Increased numbers of malaria cases were noted within 2 to 3 months following the arrival of the respective details from the tropics. It was noted that the Estivo-autumnal type died out after about 3 months in this climate. The tertian type was persistent but was rare after 2 years. Many patients received their first complete course of malarial therapy in this camp. No treatment was instituted without positive blood findings. Quinine-Atebrin routine was used in this manner; 7 days of 30 grains followed by 7 days of 20 grains with 3 tablets of Atebrin per day. A severe form of malaria in which the urine is black with blood is termed "Black Water Fever". Three patients developed Black Water Fever within 3 months after their arrival from the tropics. During the period they were hospitalized with Black Water Fever, no parasites were demonstrable in the blood. The treatment consisted of rest and support with intravenous fluids and transfusions. Recovery was complete in each instance. Dr. Bras from Java had great knowledge of malaria and took personal care of the Black Water patients. Although from time to time the morbidity rate for malaria was high, the only fatality from this disease was one patient with cerebral malaria. SURGERY: Just prior to the departure of "A" detail from Cabanatuan, instruments were requested from the senior American medical officers. Having spent a year on Corregidor with a 500-man labor detail I was well aware of the need for surgical instruments, and the fact that the Japanese did not furnish instruments for use on prisoners. My requests were refused by the senior American officers; they were naive enough to believe that all essentials would be supplied once we reached Japan. The instrument kit that I had put together on Corregidor was minimal at best. My friendship with certain enlisted men working in medical supply at Cabanatuan made it possible to supplement my kit to the point that at least we would be able to handle emergency surgery while enroute to Japan. The individual instruments were placed in the baggage of a number of prisoners; thus they escaped detection during the inspections we were subjected to. The instruments were reassembled after we settled in Camp 17. Our only available anesthesia consisted of several vials of dental novocain tablets. Two of these tablets dissolved in a small amount of the patient's spinal fluid, and injected into the spine gave about 45 minutes of anesthesia, giving us time to perform most operations that had to be done. Dutch torpedo technicians, who eventually came to Camp 17, were able to make surgical knives out of old British table silverware..... As a general rule if a prisoner suffered an injury in the mine, some physical punishment was administered underground before he was brought to the surface. This punishment was handled by the civilian Japanese overmen. If the patient suffered a broken bone in the mine, x-ray examination might be carried out at the mine hospital. We might get to see the films 2 to 3 weeks later, so we treated fractures without x-ray. Japanese surgeons operated in cotton gloves, since rubber gloves were not available. We operated barehanded. The fingernails of the surgical team stayed black as a result of our using bichloride of mercury and 7% iodine in preparing our hands before surgery. Despite our primitive equipment and environment, our infection rate in surgical patients never exceeded 3%. During our first 2 months in Japan several prisoners underwent surgery in the mine hospital, these operations were done either without anesthesia or with very weak local anesthesia and the patients were returned to us in rather severe shock. Hand injuries which were repaired at the mine dispensary required thorough exploration as soon as the patient returned to camp, usually such wounds were filled with coal dust and severed tendons had to be repaired. Eventually after a number of these mismanaged wounds were demonstrated to the Camp Japanese Army doctor, he ordered that injured prisoners be returned immediately to the camp hospital. Sharpened bicycle spokes were used as traction wires in the treatment of hip and leg fractures. Plaster of Paris was never available. We observed that simple fractures healed in approximately 2 months in the first year, by the second year in Japan the same type fractures required 4 to 5 months healing time, this we attributed to our worsening nutritional state. PSYCHOLOGIC AND SOCIAL PROBLEMS: I am troubled that the V.A. can recognize a broad range of psychologic and social problems in our current society, and not be cognizant of the fact that some of the patterns they encounter in former P.O.W.'s are long term results in individuals who had no help available when the emotional or psychic traumas occurred during long confinement. The philosophy of the prisoner of war is a strange one, individually developed to make survival possible in the most hostile environment. He first learned to laugh at the tragedies that comprised the every day life. He completely obliterated the pangs of hunger. The starving man would willingly trade his meager ration for a few cigarettes. In many instances he would risk his rations gambling with professionals who pursued their trade without compassion for any life except their own. The language problem was ever present. Interpreters, either Japanese or English-speaking, tended to put themselves in a command position so they created an atmosphere of distrust. One prisoner of the A detail was executed for attempting to learn to read Japanese. He was utilized as the target for a bayonet drill by the guard detail. His body when examined showed over 75 stab wounds. Early in the course of starvation hunger is overwhelming and the theft of food by such a person is not a criminal act. The Greek "Pavlokos" was starved to death in the guardhouse for stealing food. It took them 62 days to accomplish this execution; benefit of trial was denied. For a minor infraction of rules a 19-year-old Australian soldier named David Runge, was forced to kneel in front of the guard house for 36 hours. During the period he developed gangrene of both feet; bilateral amputation was carried out 10 March 1945. He was carried on the backs of comrades to keep us reminded of the benevolence of the Japanese. Runge has only recently retired from an active life. In camp the prisoners' life was subject to the individual whims of the guard on duty. The prisoner could be aroused from rest to undergo punishment or humiliation, whichever met the sadistic needs of the guard. Underground the prisoner was faced with falling walls and ceilings, blast injuries and entombment. He lived each day with the possibility of sudden death or permanent disabling injury..... MORTALITY: Our mortality is recorded, and I might comment that it is lower than Dr. Proff and I predicted it might be after our first two months in Camp 17. One hundred twenty-six men died in the 2-year period; 48 deaths attributed to pneumonia, 35 to deficiency diseases, 14 to colitis, 8 to injuries, 5 to executions, 6 to tuberculosis, and 10 to miscellaneous diseases. MORTALITY RATE (in percentage points) Total population 1859 (126) 6.7% American 821 (49) 5.9% Australian 562 (19) 3.3% British 218 (17) 7.7% Dutch 258 (41) 4.2% ("A" 500 (21) 4.2%) What has just been presented to you is not documented elsewhere in the medical annals of this country, the proverbial land of plenty. Certainly no human would knowingly submit to a controlled laboratory study aimed at duplicating this experience. I believe, along with Dr. Jacobs, that we survivors still face disabling physical and emotional problems which can be traced to our experience. Medical computers and the young physicians of the V.A. are, I believe, completely confused when called upon to evaluate our problems. Medicine is not an exact science -- it has chosen to deem the profession an art and a science. Our hope must then lie with those physicians who evidence art in dealing with the whole patient. There is no summary to a nightmare that was permanently tattooed in our brains, but that is how it was for those who were "expended"..... |
Leaflet explaining contents of relief supplies air-dropped at Camp #24
Page on Marine Corporal Donald Versaw, POW at Futase Camp #7, including two chapters from his book, Mikado no Kyaku (Guest of the Emperor).
Allen Godfrey Jones -- interned at Fukuoka #1 and #17